Bathtubs are the single biggest item in most bathrooms. They’re critical for setting the aesthetic tone of the space and keeping it functional. So when you start a bathroom renovation, the pressure is on: will you choose a freestanding tub or a built-in one?
We’ll walk you through the options, starting with the basics. The major difference is in the name. A freestanding bathtub stands alone and is not against a wall. In contrast, built-in tubs sit against a wall, often in a corner or alcove.
That might seem like a purely visual choice. In reality, the right tub depends on space, budget, and installation factors, not just style. Here in Cottonwood, Red Rock Kitchen and Bath are the experts on the subject–and we’ll share our expertise with you. We’ll discuss freestanding bathtub pros and cons vs. built-in tub pros and cons and then dive into more detail.
Our range of premium bathtubs and shower systems is a great place to find inspiration and bathroom remodel ideas.
Freestanding Tubs – A Statement Piece for Luxury
Pros: The single biggest pro of a freestanding bathtub is its aesthetics. Freestanding bathtubs lend an elegant, spa-like feel to any bathroom. Whether your style is modern, traditional, or somewhere in between, they’re available in many materials, styles, and shapes. Additionally, freestanding tubs can be positioned just about anywhere in the bathroom and may be easier to install because they don’t need to be against a wall.
Cons: The trade-off for the beauty of a freestanding tub is that they typically come at a higher price. They occupy more space without offering any built-in storage, so they require using bath trays or external shelving. Freestanding tubs also tend to be difficult to integrate with a shower, which impacts your bathroom space planning. Finally, heavy tubs, such as those made of stone or cast iron, might require reinforcing the bathroom floor.
Best for: Homeowners looking for a luxury focal point in their bathroom remodel.
Built-In Tubs – A Space-Saving, Practical Option
Pros: Built-in bathtubs are much more space efficient, which makes them a great fit in smaller bathrooms. There’s no need to choose bathtub vs. shower because installing a wall-mounted showerhead is easy. Being against a wall also gives you more storage space for your products on shelves or ledges. Finally, built-in tubs are usually cheaper than freestanding tubs.
Cons: While they use less space, built-in tubs require wall integration. In many cases, this means more installation labor. They’re usually placed in corners or alcoves, meaning you have less design flexibility. Built-in tubs often, though not always, feel less luxurious than a freestanding tub.
Best for: Homeowners prioritizing practicality, affordability, and space-saving options.
You can read more about freestanding vs. built-in bathtubs here.
Cost & Installation Considerations
Freestanding Tub Cost: Freestanding tubs tend to be made of premium materials, such as stone, cast iron, or acrylic. This raises their upfront cost. They often have more expensive plumbing requirements, like new water lines, and floor reinforcement.
Built-In Tub Cost: Built-in tubs are usually more budget-friendly. Keep installation costs in mind, however–these can add up if you’re not careful.
Plumbing Requirements: This is another area where built-in tubs tend to be the more affordable option. They typically use existing plumbing, eliminating the cost of new water lines. Freestanding tubs, on the other hand, usually require installing new water lines. Either way, you’ll need to choose beautiful and functional plumbing and fixtures for your bathtub installation.
Floor Reinforcement: Some freestanding tubs require additional floor support, which once again increases remodeling costs. This depends on the material and weight of the freestanding bathtub you choose. Stone and cast iron tend to be the heaviest.
Storage, Accessibility & Cleaning Factors
Storage: Freestanding tubs require external storage, which consumes more space but offers more opportunities for luxury bathroom upgrades. Built-in tubs have integrated storage for bath products, whether ledge space or shelving. Whichever tub you choose, our designers work with a vast selection of accessories to create a bathroom space that compliments your style and habits.
Accessibility: Freestanding tubs require a higher step up than built-in tubs. Because they’re easier to step into, built-in bathtubs are an especially great choice for seniors and kids. If this isn’t a major concern for you, however, a deep freestanding tub is a luxurious way to bathe.
Cleaning: Built-in bathtubs are lower maintenance and easier to clean. Freestanding tubs can collect dust around and beneath them, requiring more stooping to clean.
Which Tub Increases Home Value?
Freestanding tubs add luxury appeal especially in high-end homes, increasing their resale value. They fit best in bathrooms with plenty of space, instantly adding a lush feel. A freestanding, deep soaking tub, especially one with a view of the beautiful outdoors, appeals to bath lovers like nothing else.
Built-in tubs are more common and practical, ideal for smaller homes or rentals. They’re a great way to add a custom, stylish feel to your bathroom. In the competitive real estate market of Northern Arizona, a well-done master bathroom renovation can make your home stand out.
The decision between installing a freestanding bathtub or a built-in tub comes down to the constraints of your space, your budget, and your style preferences. Freestanding tubs make an instant statement but tend to be costlier and higher maintenance. Built-in tubs are the more practical and affordable choice, and can also beautifully follow bathroom design trends.
Still unsure which bathtub is right for your remodel? Visit our showroom in Cottonwood Arizona, or contact Red Rock Kitchen & Bath for expert guidance on luxury and functional bathtub solutions!